Skip to main content Skip to page footer

Judgments Rendered by the Court of Appeal

Selection of Judgments of Interest

Looking for a judgment?

Most of the judgments rendered by the Quebec Court of Appeal since January 1, 1986 are available free of charge on the website of the Société québécoise d’information juridique (SOQUIJ) and that of the Canadian Legal Information Institute (CanLII).

A number of older cases are also available free of charge on CanLII.

Below is a selection of judgments of interest rendered by the Court of Appeal.

Summaries of judgments
The judgment summaries set out below have been prepared by SOQUIJ.

Ville de Montréal c. EBC inc.

Civil procedure - confidentiality of the sum claimed by the respondent - tender notices – construction

Haroch c. Banque Toronto-Dominion

Class action – authorization – consumers – hypothecary loan – early repayment –penalty – rule of stare decisis – common issues

Parent c. Bain

Property - divided co-ownership - declaration of co-ownership - tacit amendment - common portion - parking - deck - permanent injunction

Avalin Group FZE c. Lauzon — Planchers de bois exclusifs inc.

Special contracts - arbitration – arbitration clause - interpretation of contract - referral to arbitration - opposability - declinatory exception

COS Construction inc. c. Paré Assurances et Services financiers inc.

Procedure – revocation of judgment – absence of service by bailiff – inadmissibility – lines of authority – calculation of time limit

Air Canada c. McMullen

Liability - Air Canada Public Participation Act - fault - injury - causal connection - extinctive prescription

Place Rosemère inc. c. Ville de Rosemère

Municipal taxation – special tax – benefit – section 244.64.9 of the Act respecting municipal taxation – adoption of a strategy – validity

Frenn c. R.

Criminal – hearsay – co-conspirators exception – circumstantial evidence – production and possession of cocaine for the purpose of trafficking

Lepêcheur c. Girard

Procedure – right to be heard – procedural fairness – absence of adversarial debate – self-represented party – judge’s duty to assist

R. c. Benbouhoud

Criminal – theft involving elderly persons – conditional discharge – lack of equivalence – hours of community work and period of incarceration

Translation of Judgments

Some Court of Appeal judgments are translated.

That said, a party is entitled to have their judgment translated at no cost, whether the translation is from French to English or English to French.

Most of these translations are available free of charge on the website of the Société québécoise d’information juridique (SOQUIJ) and that of the Canadian Legal Information Institute (CanLII).